Success Stories/Immigration/Family-Based Immigration/Family Petition Stuck for Nearly Two Years Approved After We Sued USCIS
Stuck nearly two years

Approved 8 days after the RFE response

Family Petition Stuck for Nearly Two Years Approved After We Sued USCIS

Background

Mr. L's family-based immigration application was filed in December 2024. After his biometrics appointment, he heard nothing more. With no green card in sight, many of his plans were on hold. After a year and a half of waiting, he could not wait any longer and came to us.

Challenges

The case was far beyond normal processing times. USCIS had made no real progress, and routine inquiries got no response. Waiting longer could mean waiting indefinitely.

Strategy

  • We first tried every free way to push the case forward and reached out to USCIS directly, keeping costs as low as possible.
  • When none of that worked, we planned the next step with the client and filed a lawsuit in federal court against USCIS (a mandamus action), asking the court to require USCIS to decide the case within a reasonable time.
  • After filing, we stayed on the case. As soon as USCIS moved, we helped the client respond right away so the case would not stall again.

Case Timeline

Date Milestone
December 13, 2024 Family-based application filed; no news after biometrics
July 2026 Client came to us
July 13 – August 31, 2026 Tried free case inquiry options and contacted USCIS; no meaningful response
September 2026 Filed the mandamus lawsuit
October 26, 2026 USCIS resumed review and issued an RFE requesting DNA testing
November 2, 2026 DNA test completed and RFE response submitted
November 10, 2026 Application approved; green card in production

Closing Note

Suing USCIS does not necessarily mean going to trial. In many cases, filing the lawsuit is enough to get a stalled case moving again. In this case, about four months passed from the day the client came to us to the approval. When a case has been stuck for a long time and every other avenue has gone unanswered, mandamus is an option worth serious consideration.

Will suing USCIS trigger an RFE?

Many people worry that suing USCIS will "upset" the agency and lead to an RFE (Request for Evidence). As long as the case itself is genuine, an RFE is nothing to fear. The real problem is a case stuck in a dead end with no decision. An RFE can actually be good news: it means USCIS has started reviewing the case and is willing to let you submit more evidence. That is what happened here. After the lawsuit, USCIS asked for DNA testing, and eight days after the response was submitted, the case was approved.

Outcome

Approved November 10, 2026; green card in production.

Could Family-Based Immigration be right for you?

Adjudication trends change, and every record is different. Send us your résumé, awards, and work history. A member of our team will contact you within one business day for a free initial assessment.

Schedule a ConsultationCall 415·547·9999Monday–Friday 9:30–18:00 (Pacific Time)