Accounts traced, about $120,000 settlement
Background
Ms. Y had run her bakery in the San Gabriel Valley for seven years and had a solid reputation. In fall 2025, a wave of bad reviews suddenly appeared on review sites and social media, claiming customers found hair in the food or got sick, and some posts said she used expired cream. Every account was newly registered, with a stock photo for a profile picture. Within three months the bakery's revenue fell by nearly 40%, and two cafés stopped their wholesale orders.
Strategy
Ms. Y suspected a competitor that had recently opened on the same street, but suspicion alone isn't enough to sue someone. We first filed suit against unidentified defendants for defamation and interference with her business, then asked the court for permission to subpoena the platforms for the accounts' registration emails and login records.
In March 2026 the platforms produced the records. More than ten of the twenty-plus accounts logged in from the same business internet connection, which was the competitor's shop network, and several others were tied to phone numbers belonging to the competitor's employees. In April we substituted the real defendants and served them.
The competitor answered that the posts were "spontaneous customer reviews" and then stalled for months. In the summer, during discovery, those employees were about to be called to testify, and only then did the competitor come to the table.
Case Timeline
| Date | Milestone |
|---|---|
| September 2025 | Wave of negative reviews and false posts appeared |
| December 2025 | Retained Lingtu Law; filed suit against unidentified defendants |
| January 2026 | Court allowed subpoenas to the platforms for account records |
| March 2026 | Platforms produced records; logins traced to the competitor's shop |
| April 2026 | Real defendants substituted and served |
| September 2026 | Settlement signed: posts removed, public apology, about $120,000 in damages |
Outcome
The settlement was signed in September 2026. The competitor deleted every post and review, published an apology on the same platforms, and paid about $120,000 for the losses. One of the two cafés that had stopped ordering came back.
