Insights · Nov 10, 2026

Ninth Circuit SB 399 Ruling (California Chamber of Commerce v. Bonta), October 2026: California's Ban on Mandatory Captive-Audience Meetings Remains Blocked

On October 29, 2026, the Ninth Circuit upheld a preliminary injunction that keeps California's SB 399 on hold. The law bars employers from firing, disciplining or retaliating against employees who refuse to attend meetings where the employer shares its political or religious views; the court found the business groups likely to win on their free speech claim.

Key facts

  • On October 29, the Ninth Circuit upheld a preliminary injunction, so California's SB 399 remains on hold.
  • The court found that the law treats speech differently based on its content and the speaker, and that the business groups are likely to win on their free speech claim.
  • This is only a preliminary injunction, and the case itself has not been finally decided; federal limits on requiring employees to attend meetings about unions remain in effect for now.

On October 29, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit upheld a preliminary injunction, keeping California's SB 399 on hold. The law bars employers from firing, disciplining or retaliating against employees who refuse to attend meetings where the employer expresses its views on political or religious matters. The three-judge panel concluded that the business groups that brought the lawsuit are likely to succeed on their free speech claim.

What the law covers

SB 399 took effect on January 1, 2025, and is part of the California Labor Code. Under the law's definitions, "political matters" include elections, political parties, legislation and regulations, and the decision whether to join or support a political party, political organization or labor union; "religious matters" include religious affiliation and practice, and the decision whether to join or support a religious organization. Employees who decline to attend these meetings during working hours continue to be paid for the meeting time.

An employer that violates the law faces a $500 penalty per employee for each violation. The California Labor Commissioner can investigate and issue citations, and employees can also sue on their own for damages, including punitive damages.

How the court ruled

The lawsuit was brought by three business groups, the California Chamber of Commerce, the California Restaurant Association and Western Growers Association, which together represent more than 13,000 California employers. The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California granted a preliminary injunction on September 30, 2025, and the state appealed.

The three Ninth Circuit judges agreed unanimously that the law applies only when an employer speaks about politics or religion and is expressing its own views. That makes it a content- and speaker-based restriction on speech, which must be reviewed under the strictest standard. The court rejected the state's argument that the law protects employees who are a "captive audience," writing that no federal appellate court, including the Supreme Court, has relied on that rationale to uphold a content-based restriction on private speech.

The district court had also found that the law likely conflicts with the federal National Labor Relations Act. The Ninth Circuit decided the appeal on free speech grounds alone and did not address that question.

Attorney guidance: the injunction is not the final word, and attendance at political or religious meetings should be voluntary

Shenqi Cai, Esq. of Lingtu Law Office cautions that employers should understand this is only a preliminary injunction: the case is still being litigated, and the law has not been finally declared invalid. At all-staff meetings, it is best to keep work-related business separate from political and religious topics. For any meeting that touches on political, religious or union topics, the notice should state the subject clearly and say that attendance is up to each employee, and the employer should keep attendance and payroll records.

Cai noted that SB 399 being on hold does not mean employers can freely require employees to attend meetings about unions. Under a 2024 decision of the National Labor Relations Board, employers generally may not require employees, under threat of discipline, to attend meetings about union issues. That rule remains in effect for now, although the Board's General Counsel has proposed overturning it. California's other labor laws also continue to apply.

The case now returns to the district court for further proceedings.

Related practice area: Learn about employer defense → · Learn about unpaid wage and overtime claims → · Litigation success stories →

Further reading: California Court of Appeal Ruling on Mandatory Employment Arbitration (Molina v. Triumph), October 2026: Requiring an Arbitration Agreement as a Condition of Employment Is Unlawful, and Agreements Outside the FAA Are Unenforceable · California Court of Appeal PAGA Arbitration Ruling (Castillo v. Belkorp AG), October 2026: Non-Individual-Only PAGA Cases Stay in Court as Supreme Court Hears Leeper on November 3

新闻来源:美国联邦第九巡回上诉法院判决 California Chamber of Commerce v. Bonta 2026-10-29 · cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2026/10/29/25-6874.pdf ;Proskauer California Employment Law Update 2026-11-02 解读 · calemploymentlawupdate.proskauer.com/2026/11/ninth-circuit-keeps-cas-captive-audience-ban-on-ice/

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.

Legal guidance, in the language you know best.

Your initial inquiry is confidential. A member of our team will contact you within one business day for a free initial assessment.

Schedule a ConsultationCall 415·547·9999Monday–Friday 9:30–18:00 (Pacific Time)